I vote for the change: the reply defaults to just the sender and see how it works.  Joan Knutson


-----Original Message-----
From: Timothy Wegner <tim@tswegner.net>
To: Colleague Dialogue <dialogue@lists.wedgeblade.net>
Sent: Fri, Oct 4, 2013 1:03 pm
Subject: [Dialogue] List reply behavior

This is one of my VERY FEW list messages about the list itself. <grin!> I have a question for you all.

Both of our lists are set up so that when you reply to a message, the reply (by default) goes to the whole list, as opposed to just the person who posted. This is often what people want, particularly if they have in mind continuing a dialogue that they want the whole list to see.

The down side of this is we ALL get very many three-word messages with replies like ""great!" "Glad you're home", "Our prayers are with you". Good messages, but probably not optimal for the whole list to see

The way I have the lists set up in this regard is NOT the recommended way for just this reason. I could change the behavior so the default would be that your reply GOES TO THE PERSON, not to the whole list. 

Pro - this would cut the short messages way down.

Con - If you really meant to make a substantive comment to be sent to the whole list, you would have to edit the "To" field to do this. I am sure some people would send messages just to the sender by mistake.

I would appreciate feedback on this, either to me me, or if you wish, the whole list.

What I am inclined to do is just change this behavior so the reply defaults to just the sender and see how it works. I can always change it back if folks don't like it.

I'm just sending this to dialogue, but I'll implement whatever we decide on both lists.

Tim

_______________________________________________
Dialogue mailing list
Dialogue@lists.wedgeblade.net
http://lists.wedgeblade.net/listinfo.cgi/dialogue-wedgeblade.net