[Dialogue] [Oe List ...] A photocopy of Joseph Mathews' graduate thesis

Thu Oct 6 18:34:19 PDT 2022

Marshall, 

Here is a story that I heard while recruiting PLC in Wichita Falls back in 1969 from a Methodist pastor who claimed to have witnessed it. Apparently Mathews' dissertaion had been rejected, or returned to him for major revisions, when he decided that he had no intention of doing more work on it. He then led a group of seminarians (of which the man who told me the story said he was one) to a basement at Perkins and, following a prepared ritual, threw it into the fire of the boiler

As exisiting copies reveal, there was apparently at least one back-up to the draft that went into the fire.

Take this story for what you think it might be worth.

Terry

> On Oct 6, 2022, at 18:22, W. J. via OE <oe at lists.wedgeblade.net> wrote:
> 
> Friends, I actually read most of chapter 1 of JWM's dissertation, which is a long haul. (OK, so I speed-read the last part!)
> So here are my thoughts and questions.
> First, does anybody know what happened to the actual boxed hard copy I saw in the Archives office?
> Second, does anybody know whether Wesley Theological Seminary has a hard copy in their JWM archive collection?
> Third, can anyone confirm, correct, or elaborate on the story I heard from Marge (I think) about how JWM refused to 'tweak' his dissertation, and thus never got his Ph.D. degree? Or tell us anything else they know about the origin and/or transmission of the manuscript?
> I would love to hear about this from LiDonna, Sarah B., Fishel, Lingo, Gilles, Walters, Gene, Beret, Aimee, or any others still alive whose memory goes back as far as CFLC and the early days of EI. And anyone else who may have heard this story from Marge.
> Fourth: My own somewhat vague memory is that JWM wrote this at Yale for H. Richard Niebuhr. Is that accurate? 
> (see The Founders – ICA Social Research Center <https://icaglobalarchives.org/collections/institutes-history/joseph-w-mathews/>)
> Fifth, how can we date the completion/rejection/abandonment of JWM's dissertation? I would guess that it was while he was teaching at Colgate Rochester as an ABD faculty member. Is there a date on the ms. or some kind of documentation?
> Sixth, is there a copyright notice, and if so, who owns the copyright?
> Seventh, who added the running page header that says "Chapter one mathews"?
> It just doesn't strike me as being part of the original typescript.
> Now, for the icing on this cake!
> I for one would vote to do all we can to reconstruct and correct the minutae of JWM's dissertation and produce a .pdf that could be widely available. Perhaps as a freely available document on a theological dissertation website. Or perhaps we could  reformat the text with added section subheads (you know, they did that to English translations of the Bible! those subheads are not in the original Greek and Hebrew!) and even add a contemporary Forward.
> Or even publish it on Amazon!
> At age 82 I always contemplate the option of Doing Nothing! So we could just do nothing more with the JWM dissertation.
> Plus, at 82 I'm aware of the mantra, 'Just do it now!' Or maybe later will be too late! 
> Because, starting many years ago, it was not considered exactly missionally relevant. Even by JWM. He just moved on. And perhaps he considered all that effort to complete his Ph.D. a misfire. Or a most unfortunate fire! Or whatever.
> But I encourage us to think in terms of this (admittedly bad) analogy: imagine that Picasso doodled a face on a napkin. It's still a Picasso!
> (Please let me know if you have any of his napkins.)
> So here's what I got from reading (more or less) chapter 1.
> We may not actually care very much about how John Wesley used his classical 18th century education and intelligence to understand and describe the human condition in relation to his grasp of the nature of the physical universe and his personal relationship with Ultimate Reality.
> But Joe Mathews did.
> So if you read his dissertation, what you get is Joe's 20th century theological lens applied to understand Wesley's theological world. 
> I would venture to add that, IMHO, Mathews has added a significant voice or POV to Wesley scholarship, getting inside Wesley's construction of intimate human reality by placing Wesley's words in the context of his functioning intellectual universe of Western scholarship (from Hume to Descartes to Aquinas, etc.).
> Mathews is charting Wesley's understanding of epistemology (including his perception of divine activity in human experience) and his theological anthropology.
> It's Mathews' reading of Wesley's theological formulation of his personal process of his deepening, transformative experience of 'sanctification'. 
> And, of course, it sounds more like Mathews' existentialist theological lingo than Wesley's 18th century theological formulations.
> For example, "the naked givenness of the impression" just doesn't sound like it was plucked from a Wesley sermon!
> In a nutshell, Mathews is 'decoding' Wesley for twentieth century scholarly readers. (Who else reads Wesley's sermons? I ask. Raise your hands, please! I thought so.)
> Maybe that's why it didn't pass muster with HRNiebuhr!
> Anyway, enough blah-blah-blah.
> I vote for resurrecting this hidden/undiscovered gem for the few remaining authentic Wesley scholars to chew on. And/or spit up.
> Any others of us are welcome to join in the fun by charting it.
> Marshall
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> 
> Links in the message (1)
> 		
> The Founders – ICA Social Research Center
>  <https://icaglobalarchives.org/collections/institutes-history/joseph-w-mathews/>
> On Tuesday, October 4, 2022, 09:13:01 AM EDT, James Wiegel <jfwiegel at yahoo.com> wrote:
> 
> 
> Has anyone looked at Slicker's master's thesis?   He mentioned it as his formulation of RS-1 when we visited him in 2007
> 23 Joe Slicker My Masters Degree was RS 1 <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-ly55WhjSk&list=PLUk2c_1SJ0s_SYiUeyuTyzZZ8k8AUblRA&index=35>
> 
> 	
> 23 Joe Slicker My Masters Degree was RS 1
>  <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E-ly55WhjSk&list=PLUk2c_1SJ0s_SYiUeyuTyzZZ8k8AUblRA&index=35>
> 
> 
> The thought has crossed my mind . . . I wonder whether Joe's approach -- Ecumenical Institute approach -- more on the ethical side, almost coming at theology as an anthropological study -- remember the quote to Msgr. Egan -- we tried to show the church it was about humanness . . . sort of put him outside "real" theology in an academic sense -- or maybe it was just having to type it over again??
> 
> Jim Wiegel  <http://partnersinparticipation.com/james-wiegel/> 
> 
> The unknown is what is.  And to be frightened of it is what sends everybody scurrying around chasing dreams, illusions, wars, peace, love, hate, all that.  Unknown is what is.  Accept that it's unknown, and it's plain sailing.    John Lennon
> 
> 
> 401 North Beverly Way, Tolleson, Arizona 85353
> 623-363-3277
> jfwiegel at yahoo.com <mailto:marilyn.oyler at gmail.com>
> www.partnersinparticipation.com <http://www.partnersinparticipation.com/>
> 
> 
> On Monday, October 3, 2022 at 10:04:14 AM MST, David Dunn via Dialogue <dialogue at lists.wedgeblade.net> wrote:
> 
> 
> Hi Marshall, Karen and colleagues.
> 
> 
> I’ve done a quick comparison of the four documents in the Archive (https://icaglobalarchives.org/resources/ <https://icaglobalarchives.org/resources/>) and the photocopy of JWM’s thesis that I have. The four documents in the Archive are the four chapters of JWM's thesis. A quick survey suggests that the only parts of the thesis missing from the Archive copy are the Title page, the comprehensive Table of Contents, the Introduction to the thesis and a few footnotes.
> 
> This means that we’ll have the entire thesis with the addition of scans of the Table of Contents (2 pages), the Introduction (4 pages) and the cover.
> 
> A few good copy editor souls need to compare the PDF against the photocopy to correct the numbering of a few of the footnotes and other typos that might appear—easy corrections in the PDF
> 
> 
> I’ve forgotten whose photocopy I copied (my copy is at least a second generation copy), but that means that there is likely at least one 2nd generation copy in someone else’s hands.
> 
> In any case, we’re close to having a pristine PDF of the entire thesis.
> 
> 
> This was a pleasing experience of network intelligence.
> 
> 
> David
> 
> 
>> On Oct 2, 2022, Karen Snyder wrote:
>> In light of it being about John Wesley, it either is JWM’s doctoral thesis or something he wrote related to it.  You can see what we have presently in the Archives under Periodicals here related to his doctoral thesis:  https://icaglobalarchives.org/resources/ <https://icaglobalarchives.org/resources/>.
>> 
>> If it is different, than it should be added here as well. Are you able to scan it?  If not, send it to Chicago, and we will scan it. We do scanning four days a week so it would be done immediately. Once scanned and added to the Periodicals, it is available for anyone to read it who wishes to.
> 
>> On Oct 2, 2022, Marshall Jones replied:
>> So David's precious xerox is probably copied from this original.
>> I think the typescript is also available in a digital scan on-line.
> 
> 
> —
> 
> <DMD email sig photo small-Nov2012.jpg>
> 
> "Mystery, possibility, and the power to choose"
> 
> David Dunn
> 740 S Alton Way 9B
> Denver, CO 80247
> 720-314-5991
> dmdunn1 at gmail.com <mailto:dmdunn1 at gmail.com>
> 
> 
> 
> 
> _______________________________________________
> Dialogue mailing list
> Dialogue at lists.wedgeblade.net <mailto:Dialogue at lists.wedgeblade.net>
> http://lists.wedgeblade.net/listinfo.cgi/dialogue-wedgeblade.net <http://lists.wedgeblade.net/listinfo.cgi/dialogue-wedgeblade.net>
> 
> <DMD email sig photo small-Nov2012.jpg>_______________________________________________
> OE mailing list
> OE at lists.wedgeblade.net
> http://lists.wedgeblade.net/listinfo.cgi/oe-wedgeblade.net

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.wedgeblade.net/pipermail/dialogue-wedgeblade.net/attachments/20221006/9e375de2/attachment.htm>